| Scott Faust | 112 lbs | 1967 |
| Frank McQuaide | 145 lbs | 1968 |
| Tim Mackuliak | 133 lbs | 1968 |
| Tim Mackuliak | 138 lbs | 1969 |
| Jim Lamison | 88 lbs | 1971 |
| Mark Rayburg | 112 lbs | 1971 |
| Steve Bowser | 133 lbs | 1971 |
| Paul Crooks | 112 lbs | 1972 |
| Bob Bank | 120 lbs | 1972 |
| Jim Lamison | 112 lbs | 1973 |
| Bob Banks | 119 lbs | 1973 |
| Bill Smith | 132 lbs | 1973 |
| Bruce Wing | 185 lbs | 1973 |
| Bob Mottola | 112 lbs | 1974 |
| Mark Graham | 145 lbs | 1974 |
| Steve Poorman | Unlimited | 1974 |
| Larry Moorhead | 91 lbs | 1975 |
| Don Carnahan | 138 lbs | 1975 |
| Perry Saccardi | 145 lbs | 1975 |
| Perry Saccardi | 145 lbs | 1976 |
| Dan Villani | 155 lbs | 1976 |
| Joel Rayburg | 112 lbs | 1977 |
| Doug Lamison | 105 lbs | 1977 |
| Joel Rayburg | 119 lbs | 1978 |
| Terry Moorhead | 105 lbs | 1979 |
| Doug Lamison | 126 lbs | 1979 |
| David Gray | 145 lbs | 1979 |
| Kevin Moorehead | 98 lbs | 1982 |
| Kevin Moorehead | 98 lbs | 1983 |
| Bill Roscosky | 155 lbs | 1986 |
| Steve Vak | 185 lbs | 1987 |
| Steve Vak | 185 lbs | 1988 |
| Scott Baustert | 135 lbs | 1989 |
| Max Jamison | 130 lbs | 1990 |
| Rob Beighley | 140 lbs | 1990 |
| Tom Lenox | 145 lbs | 1990 |
| Mike Flanyak | 152 lbs | 1992 |
| Doug Joseph | 189 lbs | 1992 |
| Doug Joseph | 189 lbs | 1993 |
| Dana Jackson | 145 lbs | 1995 |
| Matthew Stone | 189 lbs | 1995 |
| Shawn Fajbik | 103 lbs | 1995 |
| Chris Matarrese | 119 lbs | 1996 |
|
| Dave Faulk | 135 lbs | 1996 |
| Ean Jackson | 152 lbs | 1996 |
| Joe Chirafisi | 160 lbs | 1996 |
| Brian Egnatz | 103 lbs | 1997 |
| Shawn Fajbik | 112 lbs | 1997 |
| John Lorenz | 119 lbs | 1997 |
| Chris Matarrese | 125 lbs | 1997 |
| Scott Lowers | 130 lbs | 1997 |
| Ean Jackson | 152 lbs | 1997 |
| Joe Chirafisi | 160 lbs | 1997 |
| Keath Sherbondy | 189 lbs | 1997 |
| John Lorenz | 119 lbs | 1998 |
| Anthony DiNinno | 130 lbs | 1998 |
| Joe Chirafisi | 160 lbs | 1998 |
| Clay McKendree | HWT | 1998 |
| John Lorenz | 130 lbs | 1999 |
| Tony DiNinno | 135 lbs | 1999 |
| Adam McKendree | 140 lbs | 1999 |
| P. J. Ross | 152 lbs | 1999 |
| Ryan McKendree | 189 lbs | 1999 |
| Jeff Ruffini | 103 lbs | 2000 |
| Frank Ross | 125 lbs | 2000 |
| Adam McKendree | 140 lbs | 2000 |
| P. J. Ross | 160 lbs | 2000 |
| Bob McKillop | HWT | 2000 |
| Jeff Ruffini | 103 lbs | 2001 |
| Kurt Lorenz | 130 lbs | 2001 |
| Jeff Ruffini | 103 lbs | 2001 |
| Adam McKendree | 145 lbs | 2001 |
| Ryan McKendree | 189 lbs | 2001 |
| Jeff Ruffini | 125 lbs | 2002 |
| Angelo Manifest | 130 lbs | 2002 |
| Mike Corcetti | 171 lbs | 2002 |
| Zach McKendree | 112 lbs | 2003 |
| A.J. Milanak | 130 lbs | 2003 |
| Angelo Manifest | 135 lbs | 2003 |
| Kurt Lorenz | 140 lbs | 2003 |
| Steve Stedrak | 145 lbs | 2003 |
| Mike Corcetti | 171 lbs | 2003 |
| Scott McKillop | 215 lbs | 2003 |
| Scott McKillop | 215 lbs | 2004 |
| Andrew Joseph | HWT | 2004 |
|
